Blog

When Is A Portrait A "Not-Portrait"?
This morning I applied the finishing touches to a charcoal portrait commission of Lady Gaga, shown here.
|
It is always a challenge to combine gestural graphic marks alongside areas of detail and get them to knit together into a united whole. The person who commissioned the piece is delighted with how it looks.
Anyway, now to the subject at hand. Yesterday, I stumbled across a post on Instagram that made me revisit a question I have wrangled with at length for a few years now, and to which I still don't have an answer: when is a portrait not a portrait?
Here is the post I saw, which I love: |
|
|
While I'd really like to be able to tell you all about this artist, I don't even know their name! I've messaged him/her but as at time of writing, not had a response. I'm sure you'll agree it is a wonderful painting. *** Her name is Sher, and her account is @allmimsy on Instagram ***
"Who is it?" I view this painting as a "Not-Portrait". In other words, it isn't a portrait of an individual, it is a representation of humanity - of "human-ness". If I were to see this on someone's wall, I wouldn't ask "who is it?"
But why wouldn't I ask that?
As you know, I have painted a large number of portraits, and in the vast majority of cases, if I saw the painting on someone's wall (and I hadn't painted it!) I WOULD ask who the person was. In only a handful of cases, I wouldn't. And yet even I don't know why this difference exists!
By way of exploration, I digitally removed the red line. Here is a side-by-side, and to me, the image on the right has strayed into "portrait" territory. I want to ask "who is it?" Now, while I don't think it's as simple as adding a graphic element to make that shift to "Not-Portrait", it is interesting to note the huge effect this small feature makes to the overall piece. |
|
|
I hope you agree how that red line is doing most of the work in stopping the painting from becoming a portrait. Incidentally, I'm not saying that "Portrait" is bad, and "Not-Portrait" is good. Both have their place and merits. I'd just like to be able to understand what makes this difference.
I'd love to know your thoughts and theories on Portraits vs Not-Portraits. And, just to be clear and at the risk of stating the obvious, despite combining graphic marks with realism, my Lady Gaga drawing is still definitely a portrait!!! |


