Blog

Degas' Modern Thinking
Last week I visited the National Gallery in London. Nothing new in that. I actually went to see the Rembrandts there, to get a better idea of how he applied paint. There were great, of course. They're Rembrandts!
While there, I took in a lot of other artists' works and, seeing this painting by Degas, I thought it would make an interesting topic.

|
Combing the Hair ('La Coiffure') - 45"x58" - Oil on canvas 1896 |
Let's look at the lines in the design. Firstly, the figures sit on a "Baroque" diagonal - bottom left to top right (green) - with the "action" enclosed by vertical elements left and right (purple) and the opposing corners channelling the painting (yellow).

Here is the same image flipped so that the "Baroque" diagonal is now a "Sinister" diagonal (top right to bottom left). The feeling of the piece has changed. The action is now "falling away" with the painting almost slipping off the frame. Degas would have known this, which is why it is painted with the orientation that it is.

Two things really appeal to me in this painting. Firstly, how the limbs form a flowing gesture line that passes between the two figures. This keeps us spiralling around the image:

The second, more important thing that appeals, is how this painting is a fusion of traditional and modern thinking. I'll need to go over a bit of background to explain what I mean.
|
Degas was classically trained, and grounded in traditional painting. Here is an early work of his in Birmingham Museum and Art Gallery (A Roman Beggar Woman, 1857) It feels hundreds of years away from the painting in the National Gallery, doesn't it?
All the forms are modelled. They turn in space. They have lights and darks, and there are no outlines anywhere. |
![]() |
Degas moved with the times. He embraced Impressionism, but in a way that was uniquely his. Maybe down to his use of pastel, he seemed intrigued with flat, unmodelled areas in this art, accentuated by outlines. This is "drawing-world" thinking. Drawing with lines links in with our sense of touch. There are no lines in nature, yet drawn lines seem okay because they denote the outside contours that we would be able to touch. Much like a mechanical engineering drawing.
Here is a lovely pastel from Degas that shows large flat areas (minimal shading) enclosed by lines. Essentially, it's a coloured drawing:
| Degas - Three Women At The Races - 1885 |
Combing The Hair combines this graphic "line" thinking with areas of more traditional modelling in the focal points.
Look how there is a line on the left side of her face, and tonal modelling within her face, hair, blouse and hands. Lines also denote other areas, but not all.
|
Look how there is a line on the left side of her face, and tonal modelling within her face, hair, blouse and hands. Lines also denote other areas, but not all. |
![]() |
|
Here's the same image where I've removed the left outline on her face. Notice how she now blends into the background. The line makes her presence more powerful. And yet such a line doesn't occur in nature, only in drawing. It further reinforces my mantra that we see with our brains, not with our eyes. |
![]() |
Of course, combining lines with modelling wasn't new - look at any Cimabue from the 13th century, or the many stained glass windows. Cezanne, too, was working in a similar way, going on to inspire Cubism.
What differs for me is that Degas' lines were fluid. They were beautifully drawn, sometimes with strength, and other times with grace; often with both. Inside the lines, his paint modelling was exquisitely subtle, informed by his academic training. And it was incredibly modern of him to combine these two worlds in such a way that nothing jars.
This is what I aimed to do in my painting of Isaac - to combine flat graphic elements alongside modelled forms and make them all fit together in a hybrid world. Somehow the image makes sense to us, even though it would be impossible to recreate physically.
It is modern thinking - in line with the current "Disrupted Realism" movement - and yet Degas was doing this back in 1896.

All the seeds for modern art can be found in history.




