© Clive Bryant Fine Art 2026

Blog


When Is A Painting Finished?

The last two posts have been about portraits needing "more". Yesterday, I was asked a related question, "How do you know when a painting is finished?" to which I responded, "When there are no more problems to resolve."

 

That is the correct answer for all artists, because the "problems" are whatever we choose them to be. That one simplistic answer results in numerous and various responses, depending on the artist's intentions. That's why all paintings are self-portraits.

 

As David Leffel says, "Painting is a problem-solving activity". I must also dig out my copy of Problem Solving for Oil Painters: Recognizing What's Gone Wrong and How to Make It Right by Greg Kreutz. I haven't looked through that book in a while...

 

One way to look at the circuitous act of painting is:

 

We create problems for ourselves by painting, then we solve those problems by painting, often creating new problems in the process.

 

There are usually a number of competing problems, so I tend to attack the biggest problem I see at any one time. The one that's most annoying - another example of working "large to small".

 

Incidentally, Quang Ho says (with respect to representational art), "90% of problems are usually down to drawing; and the other 10% is also usually down to drawing." So true.

 

Let's look at what I did yesterday in our monthly portrait session. Apologies for the window behind my right, which put glare on the dark paint in all these photos. It made it difficult to see my own canvas at times, but such is life!

Pic 1

Pic 1

  Pic 2

Pic 2

 

The first problem to solve (Pic 1) is simply to start by getting some paint on the canvas. I did a VERY basic positioning sketch in paint (sorry, I didn't take a photo) to get the size and placement, then put down the dark pattern, and then the light.

Questions: is it accurate? Is it a likeness in terms of head dimensions? Is the design pleasing (i.e. is the dark shape interesting)? Is there a good contrast between the light and dark values?

 

Problems:

- The head shape was too thin (I have a tendency to make things thinner).

- Amy's complexion was more red.

- I needed more paint on the canvas (using a palette knife).

 

Working on those problems resulted in Pic 2, which is starting to look lit up, and more three-dimensional.

 

Although I know this painting day won't result in a finished portrait, I do want to get something of everything in there. So I decided to go for eye detail next (the problem being, there was no focal point). Added her right eye first (Pic 3), then her left eye (Pic 4):

Pic 3

Pic 3

  Pic 4

Pic 4

 

The problems now are:

- The eyes don't match each other.

- The neck area is too bright.

- I need to add the clothing neck line - which I'd always planned to add a touch of colour.

- The dark are on canvas right is non-descript.

- There is no concept to the painting.

 

I also have a technical problem now - the paint is too wet to layer. It needs to dry for more paint to go on top of this foundation. Plus I only have 45-minutes or so left. Not much I can do in that time. I'm also getting visually tired - running out of steam - and must be careful not to mess things up through a lack of objectivity.

 

Pic 5 is very close to the end of the session. I improved her left eye (still not right, but better) and added some hair strands on canvas right. I darkened her neck and chest, then added some colour for her top.

End of session

Pic 5

  Setup

Setup

 

The end of the session. What problems remain?

 

1. The likeness isn't there. It's close, but it isn't Amy.

2. The eyes are a bit "stare-y" and need refining.

3. The neck area is too simplistic.

4. The whole painting needs orchestrating.

5. There is no concept. Well, no strong concept. It could be argued that the concept is "light vs dark", but that's about it. It's more like an underpainting at this point in time - which, of course, is exactly what it is!

 

To continue with this painting (and I may well not continue with it), I would first devote a painting session to adding another layer to the skin (light and dark). That should help resolve or reduce problems 1, 2 and 3. Maybe even problem 4 too. Regarding problem 5, I don't yet have a visual concept for the painting. That might materialise during the process of working on it. My intellectual concept, as ever, is for it to feel alive. It's close, but it's not alive yet, mainly due to the eyes being too generic.

 

If I get to the point where problems 1-5 are resolved, more problems will probably arise; and so it continues, until there are no more problems to solve - and the painting will be finished.

 

Happy problem-solving!


Comments


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post